Managing reward: International assignments

Section eight of the Personnel Today Management Resources one stop guide on managing reward, covering: international assignment policies; assignment compensation; and home country, host country and hybrid approaches. Other sections .


Use this section to

  •         
  • Surface issues requiring attention when assigning employees overseas

  •         
  • Understand the pros and cons of different approaches to assignment compensation

  •         
  • Assist the writing of an international assignment policy in your organisation

  •         
  • Avoid your organisation making expensive mistakes with key employees

    International assignment policies

    Any organisation which temporarily seconds more than a handful of employees overseas tends to have a formal assignment policy. If the mindset and behaviour of the company is to send employees overseas predominantly from the mother country (ie, the country in which the company is headquartered) then the language used may be that of "expatriate". In those truly international businesses possessing a global mindset the more modern (and perhaps less colonial) approach is to express the policy in terms of international assignees.

    An international assignment is differentiated from a permanent transfer overseas by the fact that the home country employer expects, and in fact usually requires, that the employee will return after their period of temporary overseas employment. The assignment may be a short term assignment (something more than an extended business trip, which requires the employee to live overseas for typically up to one year) or, a long-term assignment, whereby the period of overseas employment is likely to be greater than 12 months.

    Research from ECA International (www.eca-international.com ) reveals that the most important business reasons cited when sending an employee overseas (in descending order of importance) are to:

  • Manage the local operation

  • Pass on technical/professional knowledge

  • Fill local skills gaps

  • Develop the employee's career

  • Act as company's local representative

    Assignment compensation

    The three mainstream alternative approaches to assignment compensation are:

    Host country approach: sometimes called 'market rate' whereby the employee assigned to a particular country participates in the employment conditions (eg, salary structure and benefit plans) of that country on similar terms to local employees

    Home country approach: often referred to as a 'balance sheet build-up' approach, this methodology seeks to preserve purchasing power by taking home country salary and stripping out tax, social security and housing spend to leave a residual 'spendable amount'. The company then ensures that the employee pays no more tax and social security than had they remained at home, provides accommodation in the host country and applies a cost of living allowance to preserve purchasing power.

    Hybrid approaches: can take many forms but often apply 'higher of home or host' principles when calculating assignment compensation or may take the form of a host country approach with the additional of certain allowances special to the period of secondment, or that particular location.

    Home, host and hybrids

    ECA research reveals that the following assignment compensation trends among companies seconding employees overseas:

    Each of these approaches is illustrated below together with an analysis of pros and cons of each method.

    Home Country Approach

    Home country approach

    Advantages

  • Assignees of the same nationality treated consistently in each host country
  • Differences in remuneration of equals explained by host country circumstances such as cost of living differences, hardship allowances, etc

  • Facilitates transfers from one country to another

  • Easier to repatriate to home country and sensitive to changes in home country tax rates, etc

  • Facilitates salary revisions by defining salary packages into two components, home country needs and host country needs

    Disadvantages

  • Different levels of pay for expatriates of different nationalities working together

  • No relation with local national salary structures

  • Administration of a home based system becomes more complex with the number of countries involved

  • Those on lengthy assignments (eg, three to six years) may relate to market rate (lose link with home base)

    Host Country Approach

    Advantages

  • All nationalities of equal level are paid the same

  • Works best for single country assignments

  • Easy to administer, when company has a substantial presence in the host country

    Disadvantages

  • Expatriates of the same nationality experience different living standards by country

  • Restricts mobility

  • Works best from lower to higher living standard countries

  • No link with the home country

    Hybrid Approach

    Hybrid approach

    Advantages

  • Combines elements from more than one system
  • Gives equity in host country element

  • Recognises home country needs

    Disadvantages

  • Administration is somewhat complex and specialised


    Key elements of an assignment policy

  •         
  • Mobility and repatriation

  •         
  • Principles of assignment compensation

  •         
  • Cost of living differentials

  •         
  • Home and host housing/accommodation

  •         
  • Allowances and premia (eg, location hardship)

  •         
  • Tax equalisation policy (n.b. employment and personal income)

  •         
  • Children's education/partner benefits

  •         
  • Social security planning

  •         
  • Work Permits

  •         
  • Return visits

  •         
  • Pensions

    Host/home purchasing comparison

    Home, host and hybrids

     

    1991

    2003

    Home country approach

    56%

    66%

    Host country approach

    25%

    8%

    Hybrid approaches

    15%

    24%

     


    Personnel Today Management Resources one stop guide on managing reward

    Section one: Reward strategy

    Section two: Job evaluation and grading

    Section three: Base pay and salary structures

    Section four: Variable pay

    Section five: Benefit plans

    Section six: Pensions

    Section seven: Share schemes

    Section eight: International assignments

    Section nine: Case studies

    Section ten: Resources/ jargon buster